Wednesday, October 12, 2016

MY TOP 100 ANIMATED CHARACTERS BALLOT!: THE HONORABLE MENTIONS for GEEKCAST RADIO NETWORK'S POLL!

Okay, so I did in fact hint that I'm going to be doing a few posts in the coming blogposts on animation.... so, okay, here's what that's about, some of you might remember last year, when I participated in Geekcast Radio Network's Poll of the Top 100 Television Shows of All-Time, and for those who do, I decided to post my ballot to their poll on here; you can see five the five blogposts I devoted to that above under "TOP TENS". Now, I had a lot of fun doing that, and they seem to really respect and consider my opinion, despite the fact that some of them completely misunderstood the whole point of "Scrubs", but what are you gonna do? Now, they do these lists, somewhat periodically; I participated in another one, a little more under the radar about video game franchises, which I did not reveal my ballot for, 'cause frankly, it wasn't really a well-thought-out and knowledgeable list; I'm really not a video game expert, so.... Anyway, that was a relatively minor list, this year they're doing another subject for their Annual Top 100 Lists and they invited me to participate again, and again I've obliged, and later this month, they'll be counting down their list of the TOP 100 ANIMATED CHARACTERS!



So, very quietly, although I've made an occasional hint or two that I've been working on this, in my rare spouts of free time, for the last three or four weeks or so, I've been putting together my ballot of the TOP 100 ANIMATED CHARACTERS, and just like before with my Television Shows Ballot, I decided to also, after all the ballots were submitted and in the process of being counted of course, with the blessing of the folks at, "The GCRN", to reveal my ballot, here.

No, I will reiterate, this is MY BALLOT, and MY BALLOT ONLY! As of today, I have no idea of the actual results; I'm not privy to the counting process, however you can check back on their Facebook Page, their Twitter and on their website, each of which, the links to are below:

https://www.facebook.com/GeekCastRadioNetwork/
https://twitter.com/GeekCastRadio
http://www.geekcastradio.com/

And I'll be posting more links to them on both my Facebook pages and Twitter, and here as well also, when they start the countdown and reveal the final results, and giving you links to those podcasts as well, and check them out, they do plenty of other stuff that I've sure many of you would be interested in, And I'm very honored and happy in this latest large endeavor for them.

That said, before I begin to reveal my ballot, (And I'm not doing five different posts this time, there will be this one, and one two more on this. as fun as TV blogs were, that was exhausting and time-consuming to do.) I gotta talk about the process of making this list for me, cause...- well, a lot of you are probably aware, that while I do often admonish obsessive list-making, you all know I say that, 'cause of experience, and I've made, a lot, of lists over the years, tons, I-, they didn't have Letterboxd yet, when I was making my list of every movie I've seen, (Which I still keep and have published here twice) but even considering all that, this was by far, the toughest list I've ever had to make.

By far, this took forever! I'm not kidding when I say, literally every spare free time I had, and I didn't exactly have much of that to begin with. I've actually got multiple projects going on that I'm quite busy with, and this was disheartening at times. Just trying to compare, character from films to TV shows, well, not even that, I had to go through and check every animated feature I've seen, and then go back and remember ever animated television show I've seen, every animated short film I've seen, and I'm seeking out "characters" as well, and-, there was just a whole lot of levels; I spent half the time, after I successfully collected about 300 or so characters that I seriously considered to some extent, just trying to figure out how to organize these characters, much less rank them!

Which is a whole other layer of worms, 'cause it' a little subjective here, the Top Animated "Characters"? This is a wide open thing to begin with, but now I'm thinking about how to judge these characters? Is it just complexity, is it importance, is it the quality of the things they were in. I mean, a TV show characters that's been on for 20+ years, is gonna naturally have more development than any character from just a 90 minute movie, I-, this was hard. Normally I have a generally good idea when it comes to these lists, where I suspect who will be on it, and where they'll probably be ranked, and just sorta estimate, but this list...-, this list, was really just digging into each character I could think of any trying to figure out how to analyze their character.

Basically I finally organized the characters into three groups, a group that was just primarily known for feature films we'll that GROUP A, a group primarily known for being on animated shorts on TV , a group of characters from feature films, GROUP B, and then, I had a third categories, GROUP C, which was just for shows and franchises that had multiple characters to consider seriously, in this case, I think I used five characters as the minimum to be in this section, and I ended up with. (1,2,3,4...) 14 different shows/collections where I considered a minimum of five characters for this list. Minimum, there's a few and I'm sure if you take a guess and can name them, where I seriously consider well over 2 and 3x that many characters for this list.

And it doesn't help that there actually is a l-ah-t, of great animated characters. There were so many characters I was shocked that they didn't make my final ballot, and plenty more I would've liked to have seen on my ballot, that I think it's worth bringing up, and since I'm sure I'm gonna get shit on for not including some of them anyway, and not even getting to the point of considering some others, I thought I'd go through a brief list of SPECIAL/HONORABLE MENTIONS, and others who did not make the ballot for one reason or another and why, and also, because it's also a cool backdoor way to talk about a few characters I won't get the chance to on the ballot, and also because it's a cool different way to go through some of the things I considered and didn't for this list.

So before I even get to revealing my ballot, let's take a look at some honorable mentions. I'm not doing this in any particular order, so for convenience, let's start with GROUP B, characters from Animated Shorts and Television Series that didn't make the list.

HONORABLE/SPECIAL MENTIONS-Shorts and TV Series

ERIC T. DUCKMAN



Does anybody remember "Duckman" other than me? It was big for awhile in the '90s. He was on the list 'til the very last second; I highly recommend looking that show up; he's was a pretty unique and unusual character for his time. 

FELIX THE CAT



In terms of my animation knowledge, I do go back to the early beginnings of cinema, which actually had a lot more animation than people realize, but not a lot of quintessentially recognizable characters, until Felix the Cat came around. I guess, I could've found a spot for him out of importance and obligation, but, even though he did survive well into the 20th Century in some form, eh, it's a 100 years or so later and there's been a 100 years or so of great cartoon characters; he kinda fell off the list for me.

TOPCAT



(Starts singing theme songs) "Topcat,the most effectual, Topcat who's intellectual..." um, I honestly have not seen enough Topcat to seriously consider him, although what I have seen I liked; but he's just somebody who I didn't grow up with, and that's a shame, 'cause his show was actually based on one of the great TV sitcoms of all-time, "The Phil Silvers Show", and even with what little I have seen, he still was pretty heavily considered but..... There's a few characters out there, that I kinda missed completely, eh, the biggest one I can think of, especially from those older television kids shows was Underdog; I suspect, but-eh, I missed him completely too. If there's someone on the list that I missed, I only considered characters who I had actually seen, so I saw a little Topcat, but he's still the representative of ones I probably just missed completely. Speaking of cartoons based off of old sitcoms.

INSPECTOR GADGET



Oh, another great theme song. (Sings) "Inspector Gadget, do-be do-be do, de-dooo!) Eh, it pains me that I didn't find room for anybody from "Inspector Gadget". (Penny Gadget also came close to making the ballot) I think I was the only kid my age who really knew "Get Smart" at four or five years old and got what this was a reference too and enjoyed it on multiple levels. It doesn't necessarily, entirely hold up now, but it's still got some amazing moments and episodes, and yeah, one of the best young secret sleuths of television was Penny Gadget. Great show.

BENDER BENDING RODRIGUEZ 



Okay, I'm gonna get shit for this one, and until I finished the list, I honestly did think I'd find room, at least for Bender, but I don't have a single character from "Futurama" on this list. I do like and admire "Futurama" a lot, I watched it constantly; it's always made me laugh, but I've always found myself a bit removed from it, and it wasn't until I did this list did I realize what the actual problem is; that, there aren't a lot of good characters on the show! No, I'm deadly serious, and I'm standing by this, Bender is by far the best, but go through them, what's so interesting about Fry? He's a bit dim, and he accidentally traveled to the future, that's it; things happens to him as much if not more than things he does. Leela, she's a good-looking cyclops and I guess her character is a little bit reminiscent of Kristen Johnson's from "3rd Rock from the Sun", but is she anything other than a romantic foil? I never thought so. There's the old scientist guy, who's name I can't remember, all of a sudden, um, huh. He's interesting in theory but in practice, he's more or less a big exposition machine who runs a delivery company, and there's-um, um,... I can't remember the other characters name, what the hell!? I must've watched at least a couple hundred episodes and a DVD movie of this show, and, and, there's nothing here! The pink octupus mouth guy, what he ever do that was interesting? A few one-liners, but not much. The other girl, who I think the show forgets is even there most of the time, what does she do? Yeah, I'm standing by this, "Futurama" is overrated because they don't have strong enough characters. It's good, I like it, it's funny, and it has one really cool, interesting character, and even he didn't make this list.  Came close but....

BECKY BOTSFORD/WORDGIRL



In terms of shows and characters that are supposed to be "satires" of the Superhero genre, "Wordgirl" on it's worst day is smarter, funnier and more interesting than "The Tick" ever hoped to be! I am not joking; this show is hilarious and I don't care if it's a PBS show intended for six-year-old to teach them about the English language (In fact, I like educational shows, that's a point in their favor), it's subtlely twisted so brilliantly. Any show that who's sixth or seventh best villain is named Lady-Redundant-Woman and her evil power is that she can make copies of herself,..- (Chuckling under breath) this is quite possibly one of the underrated animated shows of all-time and even the main character's interesting as a superhero in her own right. Word Up!

SKEETER

Image result for Skeeter

Okay, you got me, I didn't actually seriously consider Skeeter but I wanted to bring her up to make a point about one of the rules I was told about for this poll, which is that the characters had to be either originated or are most prominently known/recognized as being animated characters, which is why there's a few characters here that might otherwise have made the list, but it could be argued that they were originally or most well-known as an animated character. This is why I've brought up Skeeter, since she's the only original "Muppet Babies" character that didn't originate as a Muppet, which makes her eligible and not Kermit the Frog or Ms. Piggy. I did some skating along the lines of that rule on my ballot but mostly it did leave off some really great characters. 

CARMEN SAN DIEGO



Including and especially this one. This one pains me too, if you've paid attention to my blogs over the years, you might've notice me make occasional Carmen San Diego references, and what can I say, I've always liked mysteries and I've always been a geography buff, so this was right up my alley. Although to defend the "Where on Earth is Carmen San Diego?" character a bit as well, thinking back, that's the one animated children's series I can think of where through other characters, you end up learning more and more about another character, and that's the point of the show in fact. We learn more and more about Carmen as she leads us these hunts for missing landmarks; that's pretty unique. 

GADGET HACKWRENCH



Okay, I know more people seem to be reminiscent about "Duck Tales" which I certainly liked as well, but "Chip & Dale: Rescue Rangers" was by far the best show of the Disney Afternoon collection. Chip & Dale, were the highest ranked original Disney Shorts character to just miss this list, but the coolest character on the show was Gadget. She had a smart tomboy laid back southern girl demeanor, but she was intelligent, look at all the amazing stuff she built! She was the emotional core and the brains of that show, and most of the best episodes revolved around her. Also, I went and looked back at this show, one other thing I noticed, this is the only kids cartoon I can really think of, at least at that time, where ever major cast member, was essentially an adult! Think about it, Chip & Dale, weren't kids, Max, Zipper, Gadget's a grownup, they're all running a surprising successful detective agency. Even "Where On Earth is Carmen San Diego?" has a kid watching the events on a computer screen; I guess you can go back to "The Flintstones" but they had kids eventually and even "Scooby-Doo" had Scrappy Doo, although I'd debate whether everyone in that show were adults, but, yeah, that was weird for it's day. 

SHAGGY ROGERS & SCOOBY-DOO

 

Oh, eh, speaking of "Scooby-Doo", um it sucks! Always has, I distinctly remember first seeing an episode at age four, and thinking, "This is too stupid for me!" I have no idea how this show has remained popular. That said, I did consider Shaggy & Scooby for the list and seriously as well, they almost made it,  'cause Eddie Izzard's point about them being the only happy cowards of literature, um, he's probably got a point there, and that did stick with me enough to respect them, and even consider them for this list for awhile. Ultimately, they just missed.

SPEED RACER



This is the closest any television anime character came to making the list, sorry, I just don't have that much of a background in anime and didn't really have time to take a look at them before doing this ballot; there's some movie characters but, other than a couple episodes of "Speed Racer", I looked up "Sailer Moon" once, way after that was ever a thing, (I completely missed that when I was going on, even despite being a huge Barenaked Ladies fan) and that killed quite a few brain cells that I'll never get back. I also saw "Pokemon" when it first aired, eh, no, that was horrible then, it's horrible now. In fact, I'm pretty certain it was "Pokemon" even before it took off and became big, was the reason I stopped watching kids cartoons. Let's collect slaves and have them fight each other-, what in the fucking hell are we thinking there? 

ARTHUR READ



I actually love "Arthur"; I watch it now, it's very good and I wanted to include at least one character from like a pre-school intended-age show, but Wordgirl just missed, and "Arthur" has the opposite problem of "Futurama", it's got too many interesting characters; I honestly couldn't single out one. It works as this wonderful mosaic, but the books were cool when I was young and the show is really cool now. 

TINTIN



I think I'm the only one who ever actually really loved "Tintin", at least in the States when this cartoon made it to Nickelodeon, but I disqualified Tintin since he's pretty solidly more well-known as a comic book character than from this, but that's a shame.

BEAVIS AND BUTT-HEAD




Oh boy, I'm gonna get knocked for this. Um, I do actually really enjoy and respect "Beavis and Butt-Head" as a cartoon, and I didn't ignore everything Mike Judge has done with animation, more than a few of his characters made my ballot, but defending them as characters, as really full, 3-dimensional ones; I think that's a bit of a stretch for Beavis and Butt-Head and that's ultimately the reason I didn't find a place for them. There was also a couple other characters who I think did that kind of humor in a more interesting way. 


BOJACK HORSEMAN



I'm only just now getting into "Bojack Horseman", I know I'm a little late, but I'm enjoying it; I just don't know enough about him to put him on the list. 

STEVEN UNIVERSE



Oh, on top of finally getting around to "Bojack Horseman", I made sure to check out some of those "Animated Short-Format" shows that are so popular and keep getting Emmy nominations and wins. Uh, honestly, I didn't like most of them; I don't see the big deal about "Adventure Time" or "Gravity Falls" or anything like that,-, I mean, I get it, but it's just not really intriguing, but "Steven Universe", I totally fell for. Again, I don't know enough to put him on here or not, but yeah, I get it with this show.

RICK SANCHEZ & MORTY SMITH



Oh, speaking of another show I finally got around to, um, I do like "Rick & Morty" a little bit, I certainly like it better than Dan Harmon's "Community", 'cause at least here, he's set up a world here where it actually makes sense that they can seem to go and do anything and anywhere, instead of just, taking a perfectly good premise for a sitcom, and then ignore them entirely in favor of just doing whatever random crazy shit he feels like making fun or or doing today, to the point where the once-promising funny show is an unwatchable unfunny cult shell of what could've been. (Yeah, I said it, come at me! It's overrated!) but that said, um, this show just exhausted me after a few episodes. It's funny, but Jesus, reign it in, I get it, the scientist is taking his young nephew on these wildly inappropriate and awful inter-galatic time-shifting adventures; it got old on me fast. Sorry

ROCKO . 



This is another weird one where I thought the show was ridiculously hilarious but the characters themselves weren't always that interesting, but the world around them was. 

ADAM SEYMOUR DUCKSTEIN



Ah, man; I didn't have room for "Queer Duck". Awe! If you don't know "Queer Duck", look him up, really funny. Just missed my ballot.

DR. KATZ



(Shrugs) Yeah, another one I always liked, but ultimately didn't find any truly interesting great characters from it.

TED "SPACE GHOST" GHOSTAL



I know, the guy who created him just passed away, but I just didn't watch enough "Space Ghost" to put him on here, sorry.

ARNOLD SHORTMAN



I always liked "Hey, Arnold" as a kid, kinda reminded me of if "Peanuts" were modern-day and in a city, which I really liked; you didn't see a lot of animated series about people in the city. It actually kinda reminds me now of "Everybody Hates Chris", in a good way, I just didn't have room.

YOGI BEAR & BOO-BOO



I always love Yogi & Boo Boo as a kid, but I grew less and less fond of them as I grew up though. I think I just grew less and less fond of Hanna-Barbera's TV work in general however.

ALVIN, SIMON & THEODORE SEVILLE



Yeah, they've been around awhile but overall, the quality levels between good animated Chipmunks and bad animated Chipmunks work, is really wide; I can't really justify putting them on here.

GEORGE JETSON



There will be one character from "The Jetsons" on my ballot, but George Jetson wasn't it. You know, either in primetime or daytime, at no point were "The Jetsons" ever really a hit show. They barely lasted a year in their initial run in the '60s, and continued in reruns on all three major networks and it wasn't until a syndication run in the '80s did they have more episodes and the movie, and that was basically an add-on to other Hanna-Barbera programs. Just thought I'd mention that, they have a strange network history, that's all.

APRIL O'NEIL



This is the closest any character from "Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles" came to making the list. She's by far the only really interesting character, and from what I'm told and have seen, she's the only one who's actually changed or evolved significantly over time and variations and interpretations, everything else they seem to keep constant, which is kinda weird, 'cause the "...Ninja Turtles" were, never that good. (Screech sound) I'm sorry, but, no, they weren't. They had a good theme song, the original show was, decent, but not actually that memorable. Seriously, who actually remembers moments from this show, you remember the feeling the show gave you, especially in the beginning with the theme song, but the show was pretty one-dimensional and boring. The villains weren't that menacing, one or two, again, seem interesting on paper, but in practice, not really. I mean, she keeps getting captured, but hell, she's also looking for a story, looking to save them, looking to get respect in the workplace for her work; I'm standing by this, she's the only really good character. (I tend to think the same about Lois Lane with Superman btw.)

BOSKO



I think technically Bosko is apart of the Merry Melodies/Looney Tunes, but he's probably the best and most well-known of the characters that came around that were basically copycats of Mickey Mouse. There were a bunch of them, but Bosko is the only one that I think anybody really remembers.

GUMBY 



I'm Gumby, dammit! I didn't have a lot of stop-motion on my ballot, there's maybe one or two, but I'm not sure why. I always liked Gumby myself, but I doubt anybody remembers him that well anymore, as anything other than a strange little rubber toy.

LUXO, JR.



Awww! Yeah, I considered a lot of characters for this list.

ACE & GARY



A lot of characters!

OPTIMUS PRIME



Um, I didn't consider this character, at all. I'm sorry, what the hell did any of you guys see in this show? Every time I think of "Transformers" I think of that scene in "Big" where Tom Hanks talks about how boring these character that turn into robots, and comes up with a better idea than the ones they have. Even as a kid, this was just remarkably stupid to me. I do not get the appeal.

G.I. JOE



I don't get why anybody watched "G.I. Joe" either. I guess I understand the appeal of G.I. Joe, like 50 years ago, but I grew up watching "M*A*S*H" all my life, it was always insane to me that there was a kids show that was about being in the military. Screw that, give me a ring that can shoot fire or water or Earth  or even heart at you and has Captain Planet saving us from dangerous polluters any day of the week!

FAT ALBERT



(Long awkward silence) He wouldn't have made the list anyway "Fat Albert...", sucked. It just did, I'm sorry, have you watched it lately? Even taking Cosby out of it, it really doesn't hold up that well; it aged badly.

CASPER 



Does anybody ever actually think about how fucking morbid, "Casper" is?! I mean, not a horrible character, but Jesus Christ, Here's a children's cartoon, let's have a dead little kid, who's lonely, 'cause nobody wants to be friends with him 'cause he's a ghost, and the others ghosts don't even like him! How the fuck was this a thing!?

MR. MAGOO



Oh, right. It was still okay to make fun of near-sighted people. (Although to be fair, there are some good "Mr. Magoo" cartoons)

Alright, that's enough of that category, let's go to the movie characters that just missed the list.

HONORABLE MENTIONS-Feature Films

BAMBI



I know, I just added "Bambi" to the Canon of Film, but I couldn't find a place for Bambi on this list.

TATSUO SHIMA



No, I couldn't find a place for anybody from "Akira" either, but Tatsuo Shima came close.

TINKERBELL



You know I don't know if anybody's ever thought about it, but you can legitimately argue Tinkerbell is one of the most iconic of all of Disney's characters. Seriously, she's up there; who's the one who shows up on screen to blink to "poof" dissolve into something, she's actually right up there as one of Disney's most recognizable and important characters, which is weird, 'cause "Peter Pan" was such a second-tier film of there's. Good, but-eh, does anybody really rank "Peter Pan" as their favorite Disney film?

JIMINY CRICKET



This is another character that's surprisingly prominent although Disney, and yeah, it's kinda weird that he is now that you think about it, but at the time, I suspect he was more relateable, Jiminy Cricket, used to be an alternate curse word to "Jesus Christ" back then, and not an actual cricket.

BUZZ LIGHTYEAR



Don't worry, I didn't forget about "Toy Story" completely, but Buzz Lightyear just missed the list.

PRINCESS ANNA



This was the highest-ranked Disney Princess that didn't make my ballot, and spoilers, there weren't actually that many on the list.

LADY EBOSHI



I didn't have too many villains on the list, Lady Eboshi's the highest ranked one that just missed, and I think the reason is that few villains were truly complex and interesting characters outside of being villains. Lady Eboshi is one of them, but "Princess Mononoke" is full of great characters that some of them had to just miss.

DORY



I did really like "Finding Nemo", but admittedly I didn't exactly love it the way others seem to have. It was very good, not great to me, but it did have some great characters, Dory was the highest ranked, but yeah, it's not represented on my ballot.

DONKEY



As great as Eddie Murphy is as Donkey, I think it's a little hard for side characters to make a list like this. Some made mine, of course there's exceptions but, I don't know, Donkey, compared to some of the other Shrek characters in terms of depth, he's just good comic relief really.

MR. FOX



This should be more highly remembered and regarded as a great animated comedy, but I couldn't find a place for it on the list.

HELEN PARR/ELASTIGIRL



I didn't ask, and you may have noticed, you can includes duo or trio or more as one entry if they're so associated as being together that you can include them as one. I didn't ask about whether or not I could do that with "The Incredibles" as a family, but I eventually decided to think of them separately, (Well, I put Dash & Violet as one but...) but anyway, doing that, and unfortunately Elastigirl didn't quite make the cut.

MINIONS




For the records, I didn't include Smurfs either or some other group of a bunch that didn't make it as a character, although Minions are a 1,000x better than Smurfs. Including the original cartoon.

EVIL QUEEN GRIMHILDE



No character from "Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs" made the list. I know that kinds sucks, um, but honestly they weren't really great characters. I mean, hell, most of the character in the film were named after a single emotion they entailed! Even this one, and she's the best character in the film! Evil Queen!

HORSE



I don't know how many have seen "A Town Called Panic"; I know it originated as, I think a Belgian television show, but I've only seen the movie, it's weird, it's wonderful, surreal, I think it streams free on a bunch of sites, check it out!

MRS. BRISBY



(Sigh) This is the closest that any Don Bluth character came to making my ballot, and it's from the only one of his films that I actually think is a good movie. "The Secret of NIMH" is a great film, but, sorry, I never thought "All Dogs Go to Heaven" or "The Land Before Time" held up. Those were two morbidly dark films too, come to think of it. Dogs dying and going to heaven, and all the dinosaurs getting killed. Well, "Secret of NIMH" is pretty morbid too, and I guess it's a lot better than most of his lighter material. Yikes.

CLAUDE FROLLO



I'm sure if I didn't mention this character than somebody would bitch at me, so I'm bringing him up here. Yes, I considered him, he's a great character, I actually like "The Hunchback of Notre Dame" quite a bit, but-eh, I had others ahead of him.

WYLDSTYLE/LUCY



I like "The LEGO Movie" but I had a hard time coming up with a truly great character from it.

MUFASA



I tend to have the same feeling about "The Lion King" that I do for "Finding Nemo", it's very good, just not a great film, but it does have some great characters, I didn't forget about it.

JOY



Okay, so I lied, you can be a great animated character if you're named after your emotion, but she didn't make the ballot either.

THE IRON GIANT



Again, same with "The Lion King" and "Finding Nemo", very good, but not great.

PRINCESS VANELLOPE VON SCHWEEZ



Ah man, another great character I couldn't find space for. Completely underrated character.

NORMAN BABCOCK



Man, there's a lot of great animated movies these days; it's actually sad that one as great as "ParaNorman" manages to slip under the radar most of the time.

HADES



Yeah, most interesting character in one of the more forgettable Disney films. I actually do like "Hercules", but yeah, until somebody brings it up I don't think I've managed to even remember it exists since I've seen it.

DREAMER



One of the greatest animated movies of all-time, sure, but yeah, "Waking Life" isn't exactly a character movie.

CORALINE JONES



This is the closest a Tim Burton-influenced animated character came to making the list. (Shrugs) I like "Coraline", I hated "The Nightmare Before Christmas", sorry; this was at least cool surreal and strange, the other was just a good-looking corpse.

BERNARD & MS. BIANCA



It's weird that these two had multiple Disney films, like, before every damn Disney film had a bunch of sequels. It's weird that they were both pretty good movies but still, not great enough to make the list

DUMBO



I was never that big a fan of "Dumbo", I think the movie, just always seem to drift too much from it's story too often, especially as a kid. I can appreciate a sequence like "Elephants on Parade" now, but it just seem to confuse me at the time.

MALEFICENT



I never liked "Dumbo", but I really never liked "Sleeping Beauty", and I don't get the appeal of "Maleficent" either. Okay, she's vengeful, and turns into a dragon, but if you're really paying attention, she's mostly just an arbitrary villain. She never intrigued me.

CHAMPION 



People forget the main character of "The Triplets of Belleville" is actually quite a good character himself.

TED



"Ted" would've made the list easily, had I not decided to disqualify computer-animated characters that weren't in animated movies. If was just easier, 'cause that would've opened a huge other section of animated characters, and I just didn't want to do that.

Alright, last batch, of characters who didn't make my ballot, characters who are from franchises that I considered five or more characters seriously for the list. Again, no particular order.

HONORABLE MENTIONS-Major shows/brands/franchises with multiple characters seriously considered! 

DUDLEY DO-RIGHT




Sorry Canada, Dudley Do-Right didn't make it in, but-eh, he's still pretty funny.

CLEVELAND BROWN 



This was a tough one that I debated, I don't have any obvious African-American characters on my ballot, (Well, actually I have one, but unless I told you she was African-American, I doubt anybody would know) but there was always a reason to disqualify, say somebody from "The Boondocks" for being more well-known in comic book form or not really as great a character as they are a caricature, (That's why nobody from "Drawn Together" got close to getting in, even though I do kinda like that show) and of course, Fat Albert was overrated to begin with and Cosby didn't make it any easier to watch now, but as much as I love "Family Guy" and I did like "The Cleveland Show" too, um, but I couldn't really find a place for him.

LANA KANE



Ugh! Lana Kane, came really close to making the list, but good God,- first of all "Archer" is one of the best shows on television; it's that perfect smash of "Get Smart" meets "Arrested Development" it's funny as hell, but good god, I could've made a decent argument for like six characters on this show, and honestly, as great as she is, she might be one of the least interesting characters. Any other show, she'd easily be the breakout star character, just another character on "Archer".

YOSEMITE SAM



Oh, Looney Tunes, not-so-shocking spoiler, there will be a lot of them on my ballot and I thought Yosemite Sam would be one, but as I kept going, a few others I started ranking a little higher and higher, and he ended up on the outside looking in.

MONTANA MAX



The reason I came pretty close to putting Montana Max on the list, of all the Tiny Toons, and I even think I had him higher-ranked than Yosemite Sam, but of all the Tiny Toons, you could argue he's the most unique and versatile of the characters. He could be the bad guy, he could be the one you're sorta cheering for 'cause he's trying to screw over everyone to get rich; he's actually a bit of amalgam,of other characters, it's not like Plucky Duck who's clearly a descendant of Daffy primarily, but in a way, that helped make him one of the most unique and original characters on that show. He was kinda like the anti-Richie Rich, back when that had a cartoon series, that I think I'm the only one who remembers that that was on back when "Tiny Toon Adventures" started, but it wasn't on long after.

BOBBY HILL



I won't exactly say which character was 101 on my list, but Bobby Hill was really close to making this list. I'm really regretting leaving him off actually. Oh well.

RE-RUN VAN PELT



I swear, I think I'm the only one who really liked Re-Run. I'm not sure why he didn't catch on more, even among "Peanuts" fans, but he's always been one of my favorites. Him observing on seeing the world on the back of his Mom's bicycle, that was really unique and cool.

TIGGER



When I was a kid, Tigger was my favorite Winnie-the-Pooh character, as an adult I think he's a bit more annoying, but the wonderful thing about Tigger is Tigger's a wonderful thing. Not wonderful enough for my ballot unfortunately.

RALPH PHILLIPS



Ralph Phillips is one of the more obscure Looney Tunes characters, I think he only appeared in two Chuck Jones directed shorts, but he's got a lasting legacy as a character to me, in that being in that, his shorts are by far, the best film versions of a Walter Mitty character ever put on screen. (Yes, I'm counting that horrible Ben Affleck movie in that statement.) Creating something Walter Mitty-esque on film and successfully is really hard to do, so I give credit to the one time it worked.

BOB BELCHER



This was a tricky one, admittedly but I don't think Bob is the most interesting character on "Bob's Burgers", and I think if you think honestly about it, you'd agree with that analysis.

NED FLANDERS



Okay, I am a bit more critical of "The Simpsons" than others are, although nowadays when everybody shits on them I'm usually the one defending them, 'cause I always thought they were a bit overrated before and the backlash is now just too big an adjustment swing, but when I am critical, I am grading on a helluva curb here. You know an animated series is absolutely brilliant when I can't find room on the list for this character.

KENNY MCCORMICK



Same goes for "South Park" with this character.

SHEILA BROFLOVSKI



And this one. Man, "South Park" has a lot of great characters.

STEVE SMITH



I always liked "American Dad", but it always did turn me off that they focused so much on Steve, especially since I always thought some of the other characters were more interesting, but I guess I can't complain too much here; he is still pretty interesting, I think it's just me that gets annoyed by him.

OSWALD, THE LUCKY RABBIT



Ah, Oswald, the original Mickey Mouse. There's only a few Oswald cartoons that have survived, but Walt Disney created him before Mickey Mouse, and when he was forced to sell the rights to the character he swore never to do that again. He's finally apart of Disney now, after he was involved in what has to be considered the strangest Hollywood trades of all-time when NBC-Universal traded his rights back to Disney for the contract for Al Michaels, yeah, the sports commentator Al Michaels; Disney traded him to NBC for a cartoon rabbit.

PEBBLES FLINTSTONE



I know, I have no justification for this, but I tend to think of Pebbles as one of the more interesting Flitnstones character, and I have no idea why; I guess I can argue that it was the first time was saw an interesting and inquisitive little kid on television at the time, at least animated, and unlike say Little Ricky on "I Love Lucy", she didn't become a four-year-old right away or anything, Oddly, the character I most find myself comparing to her is Tabatha on "Bewitched", maybe it's the time period thing, they were around at the same time, but Tabatha was a half-witch and that automatically made her more interesting, and I-, hmm. (Shrugs) Maybe most of the characters from "The Flintstones" aren't as interesting as we'd like to think they are, and she gets more interesting by default? Maybe? Or maybe it's that, she's the dynamic that most arguably made them the most different from "The Honeymooners", that could be it. It is strange that they named a cereal after her though.

MEG GRIFFIN



Shut up, Meg. (Okay, I'm kidding, she's probably my favorite character on the show, but..., oh well.)

Alright, that's enough for now, or else I'd be going on forever. Anyway, I'll be revealing my Geekcast Radio Network's ballot and MY BALLOT ONLY, on my blogpost over the next couple blogs, one will be 100-51 and another will be 50-1, so remember that'll start next bl-

Oh shit, what a minute, I got a movie review blog up next. Dammit!

Okay, the next 2 BLOGS after my next batch of Movie Reviews, that's when I'll start revealing my ballot and revealing what I consider the TOP 100 ANIMATED CHARACTERS of ALL-TIME! Keep an eye out for that folks, and the Geekcast Radio Network for their complete results! Thank you.

Friday, October 7, 2016

CANON OF FILM: "BAMBI"

BAMBI (1942)

Producer: Walt Disney (Uncredited)
Supervising Director: David D. Hand
Screenplay: Larry Morey and Perce Pearce based on the novel by Felix Salten



I've been putting this one off for awhile now. I knew at some point I'd have to cover Disney's "Bambi", if for no other reason than it being one of those movies that seemingly everybody grew up with and knows and has an emotional connection too; it definitely belongs more towards the "Essential" part of the Canon than it does the "Great" part of it. Not that a film can't be both, (in fact they should be both) but I've always been a bit apprehensive about the film myself.

When I originally wrote this article, I wrote about this being the latest of a few Canon of Film posts I had written recently that were on films I didn't particularly like, I called it, "Being stuck on self-mutilation mode." (Eye roll) It was years ago; I was going through a dark period in my college years, and for the record it was metaphorical, I've never tried or attempt to try self-mutilation or mutilation of any kind. Just getting that clear.

But yeah, this film. it's a rough one for me; I use to think it was 2 1/2 hours long; I was shocked when I looked it up and it turned out to only be 70 minutes long, but I think that's not necessarily a flaw. The movie is supposed to be an attempt to portray, in fairly simple understanding and terms, the stages of life, from birth to adulthood, which was original back then. Now, it's important to understand what Disney was going for too, because while Disney has a surrealistic experimental streak in him, what he was often going for was to make movies for kids, and telling the stories that kids grew up with, more importantly the stories that he probably grew up with. 

Now, he would've been somewhat older by the time the book "Bambi, A Life in the Woods" was written in 1923, but the simple tale of a young deer, as he grew up, learns to talk, learns to play, make friends, get into a relationship, suffer loss and grow up into an adult and have kids of his own, that's a pretty idealistic story to tell kids. Who didn't ever hear from some aunt or uncle as a kid that someday they were gonna grow up and become big and strong? In hindsight, while "Bambi" is certainly a better and more watchable movie, it probably seems more comparable to something like "Song of the South" than to most other Disney animated films, especially at that time. "Song of the South," while buried under the Disney vault now and for the foreseeable future, was really intended to simply be a retelling of some of his youthful stories. (Uncle Remus is probably more akin to an American Aesop than any other character.) It was only Disney's fifth animated feature after "Snow White...", "Pinocchio", "Fantasia" and "Dumbo" and it's worth noting that this was the last traditional narrative feature he made for quite a while after that, not for eight years when he made "Cinderella" in fact, most of the other features we're some less-remembered experimental films in the "Fantasia" mold like "Melody Time" and "Make Music Mine" and occasionally they were essentially a cobbled together collection of shorts put together. You do get the sense watching "Bambi" that this was one of his more personal films, like he had said as much as he wanted to with this film in terms of stories to tell, and it shows with the more experimental routes he went afterwards. 

Still, it's survived this long, but I can't think of anybody who truly loves and admires it; I'd be hard-pressed to find anybody who names it as their favorite Disney film, and when you look back on it, yes there's the movie's most infamous and famous scene, but people forget there's a lot of shocking gruesomeness in the film. Amazing scenes of the whole forest on fire, there's scenes of Bambi and another deer fighting over Faline. When I was a kid I distinctly remember thinking the movie was as much or maybe moreso about the forest more than Bambi, and how it goes from Spring and Summer to that wonderful scene of Bambi and Thumper on ice in winter to see it destroyed, and reborn and searching for it to get green again, as Spring comes ever closer. 

You could read it like that, actually as a tale of the seasons or as an environmental fable of some kind. It's actually kinda shocking seeing the movie's original trailer to see how it was sold as a love story above anything else. I honestly forget Faline's name most of the time thinking about this film. It matters that the characters grow up and eventually fall in love, but it's not really important who they fall in love with, at least that's the impression I always got, but that makes sense actually when you realize he's telling a general tale about growing up and life and not really a more personal tale. 

My ambivalence towards the film, could be partially the fact that I just don't find these tales that hinge more on generalities instead of more elaborate, fully-formed characters as interesting as some of Disney's other films, either Walt's or the company's in general. I guess the only other major Disney animated feature that's a direct similar cousin of "Bambi" is "The Fox and the Hound", and I never cared much for that one either. 

In fact, as a counter-argument, I apparently once compared "Bambi" to one of Disney's more maligned animated features, "Oliver & Company", partially because that's the first movie I remember seeing in a movie theater, (Even though, I'm told "Bambi" was the first movie I actually saw in a theater) but also because of other factors, how it was a more direct story, yet was still basically about a young animal who's friends were more memorable and interesting than the main character was as they basically drove the plot and literally him through the narrative, which in that case, was a re-imaging of "Oliver Twist" in modern-day New York City, which I vastly preferred as a setting to a forest, especially for animation. 

That said, it's not a fair comparison, Disney isn't going for plot or story with "Bambi", he going for pathos and emotions, which he succeeds at pretty well. That's why the movie has survived and remains a childhood classic for everyone, arguably he succeeded more for that here than any of his other films, it's definitely the big Disney movie that we relate almost directly with an emotional feeling and pull before we relate to the plot or story or even it's characters. That's probably why he abandoned traditional narrative for a more musically experimental phase right after, 'cause music is the art form that most gets into our headspace, and therefore all art strives to achieve the emotional pull of music, to the point where you can hear a lyric or a note even of a song and the entire thing can suddenly be stuck in your head. Even the greatest movies struggles to do that, so in a search for recapturing emotion, music is the next step, and Disney knows that more than most since most of his best films were musicals, and nothing can stick in your head more than a great song from a Disney film.

Not "Bambi" though come to think of it. There's a score, but I don't remember a musical number in the film. I guess there's "I Bring You a Song", but that wasn't a song in the film, and I had to just look that up, and I guess, "Let's Sing a Gay Little Spring Song" but nobody actually does sing in the movie, it's just on the soundtrack. He really didn't want to saturate "Bambi" much with any extra complications, did he?



Tuesday, October 4, 2016

LEGAL/COURTROOM JUDGE SHOWS: AN ANALYTICAL LOOK AT TELEVISION'S FASTEST GROWING NEW GENRE! (What? No, they're actually that big and growing, it's probably time to notice, seriously.)



I should've gotten to this a lot earlier than now.

I know, it doesn't seem like something serious, but... you know, I know there's been quite a bit going on elsewise, the primetimes Emmys, the fights against critics, the comic book movies, fans doing more stupid bullshit than ever, it seems, the Presidential election, blah, blah, blah, that of course, I wouldn't get to the courtroom shows. There's no reason to cover them; they're not on the mainstream entertainment film and television radar, and nobody talks about them in any Facebook groups, and that all might be, somewhat true, but it's not really, and besides that, I shouldn't simply be reacting to the parts of pop culture that make the hit counter go up every time, I'm not interesting in that anyway. There's dozens of other blogs who work on that. You can't just focus on the same aspects of the entertainment world that most fascinate and intrigue the loudest voices of the populace, even and especially within just film and television there's so many little different aspects, and trends within patterns within genres going on, and yeah- I don't know, if anybody's really noticed, but the legal/courtroom show as the Daytime Emmys call them; (I call them "judge shows"), has really taken over Daytime television.

I know that doesn't sound like a big thing, but actually, it really is. You see, television ratings overall have just fallen off a cliff. There's exceptions here and there, but generally, more people are streaming and binge-watching their TV more than ever and fewer shows are actually being watched regularly on television. That said, that's also, partly because, most shows are most easily accessible online and streaming, other shows, like daytime shows, use "The Today Show" and those other similar Special Class News Series as a good example here, they're mostly not watched by streaming viewers, even when that option's available, because it's a live and immediate show that's more likely to be watched everyday on the air, live and on television still, and most of daytime TV, is like that. It's actually not really that necessary or relevant to watch it later; it's greatest impact is in the fact that people are watching it now as it happens. There's other shows like that, game shows, I don't know anybody who binge-watches "The Price is Right", there's talk shows, they definitely date quickly, especially these five-days-a-week shows, they age quickly and there's a lot fewer than there's been in decades and but there audience usually watches everyday; there's no need to catch up on what you missed on Jerry Springer or even on Ellen DeGenerous really. There's those aforementioned morning news shows, they age immediately. Even soap operas, what few are left, there's a couple online daytime soaps but, I don't know how successful they are, they're the most likely to get viewers through alternative means, but the genre is constantly getting less and less popular as Primetime dramas adopt more of their tropes and overall, just create better products. Want more proof, the highest-paid television performer, is not Jim Parsons, or anybody on Primetime, and hasn't been for years. It's Judge Judith Sheindlin, and that's not new; she held that record and has been getting raises since, when Oprah still had her talk show! Yeah, she makes more money than Oprah, and she's the major figure in the genre that's the highest-rated and fastest-growing new genre of television and she's the richest performer in the medium of television, so maybe it's long, long overdue that we take a closer analytical look at this genre, which has suddenly taken up a huge enough section of the Daytime Television market that it now has it's own Daytime Emmy categories.

Speaking of, the Daytime television segment it took up, let's start at the beginning with-, well, how the hell did that happen? You see, when I was growing up, there wasn't a reason to concern or think about courtroom shows taking over the airways, because there was only one courtroom show, "The People's Court". (We're not counting "The Judge" because that show was a "Dramatization" not actual cases with people involved in the suit) I remember the original version and I always enjoyed it. It was different than all the game shows and talk shows that were on at the time, and yeah, it wasn't much more than Small Claims Civil Court cases, but that was enough, it was interesting to see the courtroom process and if you ever happen to find an old episode of the series, it, it holds up. You could argue it as a early forerunner series of modern reality television. And then one day it was canceled, and that was sad, but I didn't think too much about it; Judge Wapner, was noticeably getting a little too old to do the show as well as he could, although for those who don't know this, he's still alive today at age 97, and he even had a second court show in the late nineties, a more fun one that focused on animals, but still, impressive. It lasted twelve years and I missed it; it was one of a kind and you didn't have other real life court series; it was unique, it stood out, it was informative, enjoyable, entertaining, and there was nothing else like it, and I and I think everybody presumed that that was how it was gonna be. It was one unique show idea that lasted for a bit, but didn't survive long term, but you can look back on for how good it was as a remnant of the era. Kinda like "Love Connection" or 'Unsolved Mysteries", one of those kind of shows. So what changed that led us to, well, this huge list of court shows that have been on television over the years at the link below:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_court_shows

Well, "The People's Court" ended in '93, there was "Jones and Jury" a brief short-lived half-court/half-talk show in '94 that introduced America to Star Jones, yeah that one, she started as a TV judge as well, but that didn't take off. "Judge Judy" was '96.... and then she exploded, between then though, I can think of one major highly-watched thing involving courtrooms on daytime television at the time....

(Sigh)



I can't believe I've posted this clip more than once. Um, okay, I know some of you younger readers of mine, might now be somewhat more educated on the O.J. Simpson trial now that that miniseries aired, but I don't think it's completely possible to understand just the behemoth that was the trial of the century and how it really did overtake everything, including and especially the television aspect unless you lived through it, 'cause this was ev-er-y-where! (Yeah, trust me, as good as the miniseries looked, what I saw of it, I did not need to relive this, it's all ingrained in me.) This, basically took over television and the world for a good year from mid '94 to October of '95; I distinctly remember TV Guides at one point, just listing that the trial was continuing instead of showing what was supposed to be regularly scheduled and everybody watched this, and it was just...- there's no equivalent to this that I can compare it too, but it caused a lot of television changes in the mid-'90s. There were television shows inspired by it, most notably the short-lived drama series, "Murder One", but it also inspired the birth of CourtTV, which I think is now known as TruTV, but it was basically a 24-hour-channel that covered the most infamous and serious court cases around the clock. We don't have O.J., but we have, Timothy McVeigh, or if you've lived in Las Vegas as long as I have you'll remember the multiple trials involving Rick Tabish and Sandra Murphy, and up until, I think they covered the Phil Spector trial too. And it was a hit originally, and it perfectly fit when the reality boom hit years later, but until then, they needed something to compete with that, so now that they don't have the trial of the century to cover, so.... enter "Judge Judy" and then a couple others showed up,... and now we're here.

And when other judge shows started popping up, I didn't really think much of it, I guess I just assumed that they were all the same essentially, basically following the same formula, and to some extent they are, to some extent more than others, there's a case, you hear both sides, you see the evidence, there's a ruling.... maybe two cases or three a day, but nothing overly different. (Sigh) That's a nice thought, but I-, you know that's really on me, 'cause I should and do know better, there's good and bad in every genre, it's not the genre or subgenre that's the problem, it's how one goes about doing it. And you know, I'm really not kidding when I say that, I should've really gotten to this sooner 'cause, a few years ago, I ran into... (Depressed sigh) "Eye for an Eye".



Um, if you've never come across this show before, I'm so, so sorry for introducing it to you, and unfortunately I couldn't find the episode I really wanted to post on here, which involved two women who worked at a tanning salon fighting over the boss they were sleeping with and surprise evidence included a french maid outfit and a strap-on, and witness testimony included a claim from the boss that one of the girl's was fired because she gave him genital warts and the episode ended in both of them being forced to battle each other in a mud wrestling match refereed by Kato Kaelin, yes, that Kato Kaelin, who was the only nice thing to see on this show, you know, him getting work, that was actually nice, but oh dear fucking god this is one of the worst pieces of shit that's ever been produced on national television! (I SWEAR TO GOD, DEVIL, OPRAH, WHOEVER, I SWEAR I DID NOT MAKE ANY OF THAT UP! I COULD NOT, MAKE ANY OF THAT UP!) Anyway, I posted the first one I could find that had Kaelin as the onscreen "Reporter" of the action, I guess, the Doug Llewelyn role, sorta, (Sigh) this show, I swear...-

Now, if you've watched that video clip, it should be clear to you why this show isn't listed on that list of Legal/Courtroom shows on that Wikipedia link earlier, well, this show was completely staged and faked. It didn't exactly hide it; I mean, no-, Like, say what you want about "The Jerry Springer Show", um, the, "Jerry! Jerry! Jerry!" chant, that was not then and probably not now, anything that was pre-planned, it organically came about, 'cause the fans were into the show. So, it's got that going for it. This-, abomination, um.... Okay, I'm gonna say some critical and mean things about some of these other more popular courtroom shows, but, as much as I may criticize them remember in context, "Eye for an Eye", is below, rock bottom, fifty feet of dirt and shit, bottom of the barrel, that's at the bottom of the deepest Ocean horrible, and no matter what, they're not that! Just remember that. They're not a fake, badly-stage, badly-acted, badly-produced mockery of a television series, much less a courtroom series like this shit was. This is what I'm talking about when I say I should've gotten to this earlier, this isn't a genre with a couple shows to compare with, there are legitimate tremendous differences between these shows and the quality levels of good vs. bad vs. (Looks up at "Eye for an Eye" clip) a failed abortion covered in shit, can be as wide as any other genre out there.

And since, this is a big, prevalent, continuously-growing genre of television, with a bigger fanbase and sphere of influence than we think, let's analyze, what makes a good Legal/Courtroom show? And ergo, also what makes a bad one, other than the, aforementioned obvious? Well, "The People's Court" is the originator and over two long separate runs has lasted, about 30 years on television, let's presume that's the baseline version of a successful version of this genre. Well, the main thing that really distinguished "The People's Court", at least, and especially in the beginning was that, it was real. There's a reason that the original show opened with that famous opening, that they were "Not Actors" and are "Actual Litigants" with a case pending..., that was all true (Still is in most cases). And that was necessary, because for the most part, all other times a series had tried to depict an actual court case on television had been a dramatization of earlier events, not actual arbitration; there had been versions of that going back to radio in fact, which makes sense, 'cause when there was an interesting court case, there usually wouldn't have cameras and microphones recording everything, so it just made more sense to recreate it. This is still done sometimes in fact. But "The People's Court" while, not technically a courtroom, what they did was look for real cases and offer an appearance on "The People's Court" as arbitration, meaning that their cases would be dropped and Wapner would be the settler of the dispute. Now, obviously there's other certain laws involving television, the losing party wouldn't have to actually pay, blah, blah, blah, it's not a real courtroom but instead it's a studio set, yeah, yeah, but the case and the dispute and the judgement, those were all pretty much real and more or less, that's the key to most reality/non-fiction/non-scripted shows in general, how much of the show is based on actual reality and how much isn't; most good ones anyway, do their best to make the main situation and realistic and believable as possible. If tomorrow I woke up and suddenly I found out that every contestant on "Project Runway" didn't actually make their outfits on the show and were just actors pretending to be fashion designers every fan of the show, myself included would be pissed! That's the crossing the line barrier, essentially, and in the beginning, most courtroom/legal shows did that and most of them seem to still do to varying degrees or another.

This is another difference between then and now, you see, with "The People's Court", when it was the only game in town, they could sort through all the cases and files and handpick the best ones for their show, essentially, if the complainants agreed of course, But now that there's a good dozen or two of these shows, many of them shooting in the same areas of the country, there ends up being a lot fewer interesting or unusual cases to spread out. This is when you see shows that, maybe go a little outside the realm of just, the bare basics of the case. This is why, you end up with things like "Divorce Court", or "Family Court with Judge Penny", "Lauren Lake's Paternity Court", which, I'm fairly certain is just a shitty version of every other episode of "The Maury Povich Show" these days. "Street Court", which is arbitration, but they set the series, supposedly where the crimes actually took place, so a dumb gimmick, "Power of Attorney", that was kind of an interesting one 'cause it included high-profile lawyers for the Plaintiff and Defendant, it didn't completely work, but that was funny seeing Marcia Clark defending somebody for giving a bad haircut. "Texas Justice", where the gimmick is, a courtroom in Texas, with a Southern judge? (Shrugs) What's the new one, "Hot Bench", with 3 JUDGES, ooh! (Judge Judy came up with that one btw) "Moral Court", that one's downright obnoxious; it's not based on the law, it's based on which person more morally in the right, which yeah, it was exactly what you think is was, just some preachy judge, yeah, big hit with the family values crowd. Basically the kind of show that was really only good for-eh, something for "Talk Soup" or "The Soup" to make fun of.

Like, I said, the farther away they got from...-, (Wait, what the hell's "Sex Court"? [Clicks Wikipedia link. Shocked expression!] The Playboy Channel had a courtroom show!)

(Ten minutes later)

(Holding back embarrassed laughter) Oh-kay, I cannot post a link to that, but-um, definitely not a legally realistic court show, at all; still way, way, better than "Eye for an Eye" though.

Anyway, the farther away from the basic court premise you get, at least having that as the center of the series, the worst these shows tend to be. I mean, this is as basic a conflict as you can get, plaintiff vs. defendant, there's a reason why lawyer shows in Primetime have worked forever and why detective stories have worked forever and why pretty much anything law-based can work as a show if done right. It's realistic, it actually happens, the conflict is natural. Two sides, having a disagreement, there's not much more you need here.

So, what are the shows that add more? Well, the only "Non-Traditional Court Show" to win the Emmy award for best Courtroom Series was "Last Shot with Judge Gunn". This show, didn't seem to last long, and I'm going off the notes and what few clips I can find, it is basically "Celebrity Rehab", without the Celebrities, or really the rehab, and it's based around a courtroom. Now it's intentions are interesting, it's actually on a program, a television program, that Judge Mary Ann Gunn implemented in her state Arkansas, but this is basically a reality program which is disguised as a court show, where the defendants are all drug users, (In fact, it's often been criticized for calling itself a "Drug Court" and they must go through this program and we see the results of that program and they must stay sober throughout the whole time.) Despite the Emmy win, this show was pretty panned even from many drug court advocate groups and frankly, watching this episode I found on Vimeo, uh, this is basically a melodrama reality series and it's pretty much just preaching through the tool of exploitation. Not that drug abuse isn't a problem that shouldn't be admonished, and that's not even inherently a bad thing to weave into a courtroom show, but "non-traditional" is right. If this show, was in a regular 4 white walls room and the judge was in normal t-shirt and jeans, and the people talking to her, updating on information were just her associates, also in common clothes, not much really changes. If anything, this is a better idea for a soap opera than a judge show! Or, a segment on "Dr. Phil." or something like that.

That's where these shows tend to go, you know how I mentioned that there's fewer and fewer talk shows than their used to be on daytime? Well, that's true, but lately, if you watch some of these lesser judge shows, you basically can look at them and the plaintiff and defendant and realize, that they basically are just talk shows now. Instead of a moderator, you have a literal judge. Let's take, one of the more popular shows "Judge Mathis", that's been on the air for 17 years, one of the longest lasting courtroom series and judges on television, and, it's barely a courtroom show. I mean, even looking at the introductions of the litigants when they walk up to their podiums, let's grab a random episode here, and just listen to how the narrator discusses their case, and compare that to an old "The People's Court" episode. (Or even, most new ones for that matter)



Yeah, there's talk about, the two litigants bitching about the other and their personal lives and how they feel about each other, and then, "Oh, by the way, the case is about a phone bill." Did you catch that? All this, how horrible she is, how horrible she is worst," and we're suing over a phone bill. Yeah, imagine this isn't a case, and this was, an old episode of "Sally Jesse Raphael" would you know the difference? (And no, most of the cases themselves, they rarely ever focus on the case, just the character and behaviors of the litigants and then, maybe talking a bit about what they're suing over) Now, it's seventeen years later after the show originally aired and sure things change, and a lot of "Judge Mathis"'s appeal is that, he's got a decent backstory, somebody who started as a criminal and then dealt with a lot of these issues and demons that his litigants deal with but also overcame it to become a lawyer and then a judge, there's a certain appeal to that. Come to think of it, it also sounds like a lot of the appeal of Montel Williams back when he had a talk show. Yeah, you see what I mean when I say, these courtroom shows are basically modern-day talk shows? Mathis is Montel Williams, without those annoying Sylvia Browne episodes, Judge Judy is Morton Downey, Jr. yelling and flipping out and insulting the litigants every chance she gets, Judge David Young, who was a good judge the first season despite a wonderfully flamboyant personality, just became Maury Povich by the end 'cause every episode had a lie detector test. (There's a couple shows that are basically revamped Maury Povich shows, and more importantly, lie detector test results aren't valid pieces of evidence in court!) And obviously, "Eye for an Eye" was just, Jerry Springer meets bad years of Jenny Jones, meets, who's that other awful one, the British guy that's on now? That guy. Judge Hatchett's probably Sally Jesse Raphael, always trying to fix and get to the root cause of things, often involving helping people, Judge Pirro is, well, she's just a publicity whore it seems like most of the time, but she's probably that guy on "Loveline", not Adam Corolla the other one. Dr. Drew Pinsky, only political legal consultant instead of, just a random former celebrity psychiatrist, sorta who shows up in weird places for interviews and to keep what's left of his fame. I'm sure this game could go on and on really but, that's what happened, this genre didn't necessarily take over, it evolved, or devolved into a meld of some of the other shows it was surrounding, to the point where those shows, have kinda begun to get faded out as these other exploitative shows, based around a courtroom, have taken over.

That's not to say exploitative is bad, I like most of those talk shows and hosts I mentioned, there's exploitation going on from all sides when you get into these non-fiction programs and it's really not as bad as some may claim, for the most part. (Have I mentioned how awful "Eye for an Eye" is in the last five or six paragraphs? I have? Multiple times? Really doesn't feel like I've gotten that point across enough yet, to me!) But, talk shows can get away with that, really the only limitations those shows have, they can set for themselves; all you need for them, is to have people come on and then they talk about, whatever they talk about. Now, I should mention that before the invention of the Legal/Courtroom Series category at the Emmys, these shows would submit as talk shows, which makes some sense, actually, there wasn't an equivalent, and yeah, it is basically talking, it's just talking within a parameters of a courtroom setting through the conversation format of arbitration, so there's an argument to be made that this isn't that big a stretch, but I'm not 100% sure I buy that. You expect those kinds of guests to randomly come in and out and air their grievances on a talk show, on a legal/courtroom show, I expect the case to be the focus and the central aspect, and all the best judge shows I've seen they tend to stay that way. It's shocking and surprising for a minute to start watching what you think is a judge show and then to suddenly see it burst into Jerry Springer, or Sally Jesse Raphael but after the novelty's over, I can get that elsewhere;

I'd rather watch the actual arbitration and trial. I mean, there's nothing wrong with having a different judge and approach to the case, the same thing there's different talk shows hosts and that's definitely the x-factor when it comes to these shows too, the judges themselves, which ones are really the best and better suited for this format on television than others. There's a few good examples, I miss "Judge Alex" for instance that was a very underrated courtroom show, he seemed like a good, intelligent judge, who did focus as much on the law and the case at hand as possible and still seemed like a human being; he's one I always liked. While "Judge Judy", technically doesn't stray as far as some of her competitors from the arbitration and case aspects of the classic formula, she's so damn abrasive and bitchy, especially lately where she just looses it against litigants at times without any real justification, that I find her unwatchable especially lately, she just seems to flip out and yell and be so above-it-all that, I honestly don't understand her appeal, at all, anymore, but for a better example of how a judge can effect the quality of a judge show, let's go back to "The People's Court", 'cause this show in it's current incarnation has had had multiple judges over the years, so we can compare and analyze them. It started with former New York Mayor Ed Koch as it's first judge, and you know, Ed Koch is not exactly politically somebody I agree with, but as a judge and a character, he was an entertainment flamboyant curmudgeon, and going back to watch over some of his episodes, 'cause I don't honestly remember too much of his reign on the show, he's entertaining and fun; I don't know if he liked doing it, that's probably the biggest problem with him, but he seemed affable enough, but he was eventually replaced with Judge Jerry Sheindlin. If that name sounds familiar, he was and is "Judge Judy"'s husband and he was a former New York State Supreme Court justice, ("Judge Judy" was mostly a family court judge when she wasn't a prosecutor.) and was a little less abrasive and cruel than his wife on the show, but I still remember him, often just stopping in the middle of the case for some preachy anger-filled rant about who did what most of the time. I mean, it wasn't with the confrontational wit of his wife or just an overall aggressive approach to being a judge that she brought but I didn't care for it and the ratings fell, and unlike some television judges like Christina Perez, who's had like three or four different shows it seems, (All of them seem good btw) he didn't find any other work on television as a judge and that's probably for the best. So, three seasons in, and they then decide to switch again to their current Judge, Marilyn Milian, who is, for my money is the best of these Judges on TV. Her run has actually outlasted Judge Wapner's long run, and she's funny, smart, deals with the case, and sure, she can get angry and upset at times, even lash out at the litigants, but it's always within the context of the case and arbitration, and yet, unlike Judge Judy, she's got more of a logical and analytical approach to the law, judges, what seems to be a very fair judge most of the time, (I didn't even think that of Wapner much of the time to be honest)  and yet has clearly got a distinctive personality and even a sense of humor. She's doesn't seem to be so above and beyond the litigants,- I can't find many faults with her as a Judge on a courtroom show. Her own personality and approach sure, but it's still about the case and the litigants and the law more than anything, and she doesn't take over the show more than necessary, and she's not boring; she wants to be there; she's inserts herself and she overtakes the show when necessary and not more or less.

So, what is the verdict here? Well, I think a good courtroom show is a good courtroom show, and a bad one is a bad one, that's nothing new. But I do think it's important to look at them critically instead of just as mindless unimportant daytime entertainment, 'cause there's a lot more going on in this genre that people seem to notice and it's time for people to notice, especially since these kinds of show are probably the future of television. I know that seems a bit much and hard to believe, but television at it's best is a medium of immediacy, and for better and for worst, daytime television, with a constant rotation of news shows, talk shows, game shows, and now courtroom shows is at the core of modern television, the shows that get people to turn on their television and those that watch those shows, watch them everyday. It's probably best to keep an eye on how this newest major genre of daytime is going and continues to evolve and devolve, 'cause it's not going away and there's a slew of wannabes and imitators coming in on the genre, and if you think we're overrun with the genre now, well hang tight folks, 'cause this is still young and it's only gonna get bigger in the immediate future.